Friday, August 31, 2012

Summary of August 2012 Board Meeting


Present: Directors: Ted Ariev, Charles Bressler, David Robinson, John McNerney, Steven Schattman, Herman Stekler, ECA General Manager Jim Santos, ECA Assistant Manager Wanda Powell, Legum & Norman Community Manager Greg Roby, William Perry, Legum & Norman Regional Manager, recording secretary.

Absent: Ilo-Mai Harding

President’s Statement
--The board will conduct a planning workshop to address major improvement projects regarding priority of action and what to do about financing these projects.

--Alex Robinson, a past ECA president, died August 19, 2012.

Treasurer’s Report
There is currently 30% rental occupancy in the Elizabeth.

ECOBECO Presentation

According to the Maryland Public Service Commission, by 2015, we need to reduce electric consumption by 15% or face rolling brown outs.

ECOBECO, a company to support the EmPower Maryland Energy Efficiency Act of 2008, will offer every Elizabeth unit (renters included) the opportunity to participate in an energy audit that will provide free-of-cost CFS bulbs, faucet aerators, and smart power strips. Go to the concierge desk to get your ECOBECO folder. If every apartment participates, ECBECO estimates the Association will save $60,000 per year in reduced utility bills.

The ECA board approved hiring two Securitas guards to accompany ECBECO personnel to apartments requesting the energy audits.

Management Report

--Elevator hoist motor replacement continues to be delayed for another 5-6 weeks.

--Three surveillance cameras were installed in the West lobby.

--Board approved hiring Wiss, Janey to do three separate repairs one concerned with water penetration in two apartments, the second to scope out the repair of unstable masonry at the roof line, and the third address water intrusion through the electrical vault and the G-2 garage level. These repairs might cost as much as $42,000.

Committee Report Highlights

--Staff Handbook: progress is being made on employee job descriptions. Staff positions within the Elizabeth had no written job descriptions.

--Social: now being led by Judy Gann and Deborah Ariev.

--Landscape: working on estimates for fall plantings that will include pansies. The committee and Ruppert have identified some over-watering problems.

Energy: call for more volunteers.

--Bylaw Amendments: a second letter that includes a survey will go out after Labor Day.

After Hearing the Experts, Time for Action


Those Elizabethan Condominium owners know if they attended the expert briefings this summer, read the executive summaries, or browsed through the hundreds of pages presented by the hired consultants that building elements, such as balconies, doors and windows and our heating and cooling units, are well past their useful lives.

THE BRIEFING FROM THE STRUCTUAL ENGINEER

Hearing Kenneth Kosteva, the Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates engineer who was involved in evaluating the Washington Monument and the National Cathedral after last year’s earthquake damage say that the ECA must attend to balconies and balcony doors as well as window replacement and backing up that pronouncement with detailed information made it irrefutably clear that we must attend to this situation immediately and that we must make these repairs correctly. He also made it painfully clear that we must not do a halfway job or else we would be wasting our time and money. He said halfway repairs are done when investors want to flip a property and get rid of the financial burden of owning something that is inferior.

Need I say the Elizabeth is home to the greater majority of people who are owners and we live in a desirable neighborhood with many conveniences and low crime rates? Shall we say that investing in the proper repairs will restore the quality of life we believe we all deserve?

The good news on window and balcony door replacement is that it will help regulate temperature within the units, bring down energy costs, contribute to resolving mold problems, do away with asbestos implanted in the walls, and stop water penetration. The bad news is that this project will take two years to complete and cost an estimated $5.3 million.

THE BRIEFING FROM MECHANICAL ENGINEER

The briefing on heating and cooling restoration from Mr. Mendoza of Mendoza, Ribas, Farinas & Associates ran along the same lines. The original hvac units within the apartments are beyond their useful lives, failure is imminent, and replacement will bring numerous benefits. Mendoza’s current estimate for replacing an in-wall McQuay unit runs about $5200 without the cost of fixing drywall or other details impacted by such a replacement. He had no estimate at this time for the smaller visible units but clearly these units would cost less than the in-wall units to replace.

What would be ideal in the replacement of the hvac units is to have a coordinated building-wide plan where all hvac units are replaced probably tier by tier. This would benefit everyone because it would minimize the disruption time and ensure that every unit was replaced.

The bad news is that coordinated building-wide plan is not possible at this time. Why? Because our ECA bylaws make every apartment owner responsible for the cost of replacing their hvac units. Some owners on limited incomes say they cannot afford to make such a costly repair and that until the hvac units fail, they will not replace them. What will happen is that apartments surrounding and underneath failing hvac units will suffer damage, usually water damage, as the old hvac units continue to age.

WHAT CAN BE DONE?

--First of all, attend the monthly meetings to understand the issues we all face in this Association.

--If possible mark your calendar for Wednesday, September 5, 2012, at 7 pm when the board will conduct a workshop to prioritize pressing repairs and restorations, form an action list, begin development of a financing plan, and outline a process for implementation of the work.

--Attend the informal Sunday evening gathering on September 9 at 7 pm to ask questions about the issues we are facing.

--Vote affirmatively to approve bylaw amendments that deal with unit owner insurance and reducing bylaw vote requirements from 75% to 66 2/3%. Wouldn’t you prefer to be able to change the bylaw that makes hvac unit replacement your financial responsibility so that the Association can assume that burden? If the Association was financially responsible for hvac replacement, than everyone will benefit from a coordinated building-wide replacement plan and owners on fixed incomes can participate without facing sudden bills totaling thousands of dollars.

--Be proactive and join a committee to improve the quality of life in the building. The energy is looking for help for example. Call Joan Rosenbach at 301-657-3241.

Just remember if you owned a single-family home, all the costs for repairs and the responsibility for making those repairs would fall on your shoulders. Stay informed. Be proactive to protect your investment. Be proactive if your home is here at the Elizabeth.

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Minutes of July 2012 ECA Board Meeting


THE ELIZABETH CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION
4601 North Park Avenue
Chevy Chase, MD 20815

Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting   July 24, 2012

Board Present:
Ted Ariev                        President
David Robinson..............Vice-President
John McNerney ............   Treasurer
Herman Stekler .............   Asst. Treasurer..................
Ilo-Mai Harding............... Secretary
Charles Bressler                Director
Steven Schattman ............Director

Others Present:
Gregory Roby ............ Senior Community Manager, Legum & Norman
James M. Santos .........ECA General Manager, Legum & Norman
Jana Bowcut ...............ECA Recording Secretary, On the Record


On June 26, 2012, in accordance with Section 11.109.1 of the Maryland Condominium Act, the Board met in executive session.

Call to Order:  Mr. Ariev called the meeting to order at 7:33 p.m.

Approval of Meeting Minutes:

MOTION         Mr. McNerney moved that the amended minutes of the meeting of the Board of Directors on June 26, 2012 be approved. Mr. Schattman seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously (7-0-0). 

President’s Report: Mr. Ariev provided an update on the maintenance, repair and replacement program. Reports have been received from all consultants and are available to residents at the front desk and management office. The full report, which is 200 pages long, will be available to the Board tomorrow morning, and executive summaries, 20 pages long, will be available to all owners. Consultants will be on-site to make presentations on July 31 and August 14 at 7:30 p.m. David Robinson, Jim Santos and Ted Ariev have met to fill in some gaps in the report, such as finalizing the budget of the corridor and communication systems, which are to be considered in the final cost of the program. This will be presented to the Board, owners and residents.

Mr. Ariev addressed the issue of smoking, which was raised by a resident at the June board meeting. According to the by-laws, owners have the right to the use of their apartments, except in cases where it becomes a nuisance or health issue for other residents. The Board cannot take away a person’s right to smoke, but if it becomes a severe nuisance, it can be brought to the Board’s attention. Dr. Al Muller is knowledgeable about this issue and has agreed to assist the Board and management in handling smoking-related issues as they arise.

Much progress has been made with regard to trash removal in the garage. Mr. Santos and staff have worked hard to clear trash, and will continue to do so.

At the last meeting, Dr. Muller and others raised the question of the types and number of social events. Once the chair of the social committee, Judith Barth, returns from vacation, this will be reviewed by the Board.

Treasurer’s Report: Mr. McNerney provided the following report:
As stated in tonight’s agenda notes, the financial reports for the end of our fiscal year, June 30, are not available. ECA books are kept on an accrual basis, and the calculations for closing the books at the end of the fiscal year are far more involved than those for closing the books on a monthly basis.

The financial reports for both the end of the fiscal year and for the month of July will be presented at the August Board meeting.

Delinquencies through July 16 total $56,000. Six accounts are in collection.

Management Report: Mr. Roby reiterated that the June financials are not available until the books for the ending fiscal year are closed.

Mr. Santos provided the following management report:

·       Beginning Monday, the elevator hoist motor replacement will begin, starting with elevator #3. This work will present some inconveniences to residents, and could require the car to be out of operation for 30 days...

·       Three additional surveillance cameras are needed in the West lobby.

MOTION        Mr. Bressler moved, Mr. Stekler seconded to authorize Electronic Security Services ESSI to install three additional color cameras for surveillance monitoring of the West Lobby. The cost of this work and installation is $2,747, labor parts and tax included. The motion passed unanimously (7-0-0).

·       Loose ceramic tiles and cracked mortar joints on the exterior walls of the commercial arcade need to be addressed.

MOTION         Mr. Bressler moved, Mr. Robinson seconded to authorize Manders Decorating to remove loose tiles from exterior walls of each commercial unit on the arcade level. The work includes securing tiles and mortar joint replacement at a cost of $3,500. The motion passed unanimously (7-0-0).

·       The website is now up and running. Residents should log in as new members, but prior log-in names and passwords can be used.

·       As discussed in the June board meeting, Mr. Santos had guidelines on driving into the garage placed in the ECA newsletter.

·       Mr. Santos met with fire department personnel and announced that instructions for residents with limited mobility will be posted on the bulletin board as soon as these are provided by the fire marshal.

·       A solar company has been contacted to begin exploring the possibility of installing solar panels. Their initial opinion is that solar panel application is feasible.

Committee reports:

Energy Committee: Lynn Thayer,  filling in for Joan Rosenbach, reported that the committee has decided to use EcoBeco to provide energy saving solutions to the building. A representative from EcoBeco has been invited to the August 28 meeting. If the Board approves the energy committee’s proposal for this work, information tables will be set up in the east and west lobby to answer questions and educate residents. EcoBeco will replace light bulbs with CFLs, put aerators on faucets and install “smart” power strips at no financial cost to the Elizabeth. If a significant number of residents participate, it could give the Elizabeth substantial savings in energy costs. 

Floor Reps: Floor representatives have welcomed 16 new residents who have moved in since July 1.  Twenty-two residents volunteered to use their language skills to assist new residents. A total of ten languages are offered, and new language volunteers are welcome.

Library Committee:  The committee chair thanked residents for their generous donations. However, there is a severe shortage of space, and future donations should be in new/good condition, and of general interest. The committee will explore obtaining more space. Mr. Ariev stated that he will support finding additional space for the library.

Landscaping Committee: The committee recently met and took stock of plants not doing well. The committee will soon meet with the landscapers to make decisions on annual plants.  

Resident Comments:

Molly Frantz, Unit 1007, asked about the timetable for the maintenance, repair and replacement program. Mr. Ariev stated that there will be a series of special meetings to address the reports. A meeting will be held on August 14 to discuss the Mendoza report, and related issues will also be discussed at the August 28 Board meeting.

Ms. Frantz also asked about the building’s liability if the pool is open but no lifeguard is on deck. Mr. Santos responded that the pool should never be open without a lifeguard present. He stated that the issue of a missing lifeguard has been addressed with the pool management company, and there will always be a lifeguard at the pool when it is open.   

Ms. Frantz asked about a previous refund that ECA received on a tax for utilities, and wanted to know if the Association was still paying. Mr. Roby stated that the Association has not been taxed after the refund.

Judy Gann, Unit 711, stated that she was unable to log on to the new ECA Website. She emailed someone at Associa, who told her that she had to send a copy of her condo deed. Mr. Santos stated that this was not accurate and he will investigate.

Stephanie Olshan, Unit 1014, expressed concern over pets urinating in the elevator. She asked why this could not be reviewed on film in order to hold residents responsible. Mr. Santos stated that he was only aware of one incident of water on the floor, which was from a bather, not an animal. He stated that residents should report all incidents to the front desk, noting the time of occurrence, so that tapes can be reviewed. He will talk to staff to make sure that these incidents are logged properly. Several other residents voiced complaints about animals urinating in elevators and in the garage.

Maurice Trebach, Unit 1407, expressed concern about the size of dogs in the building. Mr. Santos stated that the by-laws and house rules state that a small orderly dog, a cat, or a caged bird is allowed.

Another resident stated that the pet issue was examined by a committee a couple of years ago, and the notes are available.  Weight limitation was removed years ago. 

Adrienne Vanasco, Unit 1609, asked that an ongoing record be kept of issues in the building. For example, at the last meeting there were discussions of having action reports available after fire alarm incidents, and curbing outsiders from parking in the garage.

Al Muller, Unit 411, stated that every animal incident that was reported and checked on camera footage turned out to be pool water. Dr. Muller thanked the Board for coming up with executive summaries of the consultant reports. He also praised Mr. Ariev’s cover letter. Dr. Muller noted that some projects may not need to be addressed, such as the exterior canopies.

Mr. Bressler stated that a letter to residents is ready for distribution that explains why a vote by residents is required to change the voting percentage from 75% to 66% to change the by-laws.

Jim Jones, Unit 307, stated that to get on the new Website a code is needed, which is on each resident payment stub for their monthly payments. Residents can then select a user name and password.

Dr. Snyder, Unit 1120, asked if the new fire alarm system will have a signal to tell residents if an alarm is real or false. Mr. Ariev stated that this will be part of the overhaul of communications systems in the building, which will be addressed over the next few years.


Adjournment:
The President adjourned the meeting at 8:35 p.m., with the Board to meet immediately after for an executive session, in concordance with section 11.109.1 of the Maryland Condominium Act.

The initial draft of the minutes, upon which these minutes are based, was prepared by Jana Bowcut of On the Record.

Respectfully submitted,
Ilo-Mai Harding, Board Secretary

Monday, July 30, 2012

Summary of July 2012 ECA Board Meeting


Present: Directors: Ted Ariev, Charles Bressler, Ilo-Mai Harding, David Robinson, John McNerney, Steven Schattman, Herman Stekler, ECA General Manager Jim Santos, ECA Assistant Manager Wanda Powell, Legum & Norman Community Manager Greg Roby, William Perry, Legum & Norman Regional Manager, recording secretary

President’s Statement

--Capital Improvement Projects: The consultants have completed their work on accessing what needs to be done in the Elizabeth to preserve, repair, and improve the property. Two briefing for owners will be held July 31 (Structural consultant Ken Kosteva) and August 14 (Mechanic consultant Walter Mendoza) to discuss highlights of the recommendations. An executive summary has been distributed to all owners through the front desk. Ted Ariev urges all ECA members to attend these important  meetings.

--Smoking: Ariev has appointed Al Muller to hear all complaints about smoking that creates a nuisance or health issue for neighbors.

--Social Activities: Ariev supports the ECA community coming together for social activities and expects to have a schedule of activities in the near future.

Treasurer’s Report
The fiscal year ended June 30 and a full report will be available at the August meeting.  As of July 16, there were six delinquent accounts.

Management Report
Elevator Project: July 30 (subsequently postponed two weeks due to nondelivery of needed parts) will begin replacement of the hoist motor for Elevator #3. The work could take as long as 30 days and depends on when County inspectors are able to review the work. When work on Elevator #3 is complete, the project will move to the opposite tower.

Surveillance Cameras: The ECA General Manager asked for approval to buy 3 new cameras to improve security in the building. The Board approved the purchase.

Arcade Tile Work: The ECA General Manager asked for approval to repair wall tiles in the Arcade. The Board approved the expense.

Website: The new website is up and running. Elizabethcondo.com

Alternative Energy: It has been determined that it is possible to put solar panels on the roof. These panels could provide an economic energy resource for the Elizabeth.

Committee Reports
Energy: Eccobecco will present a cost saving plan at the August 28 ECA board meeting.

Library: The library shelves are at capacity. Ted Ariev said he will find more space for books.